In today's dynamic and competitive job market, the question of whether employees have a fundamental right to a pay rise is a topic that can create passionate debates. As employees dedicate their time, skills, and energy to their roles, the expectation of fair compensation for their contribution to the business naturally arises. 
However, due to uncertain economic conditions and changing dynamics between employer and employee, the question of guaranteed pay increase can be one that is avoided. 
In this blog, it covers the issues surrounding pay increase and what businesses should take into account. 

Statutory minimum wage and contractual agreements 

The Government sets minimum wage rates that businesses must adhere to, usually adjusting them annually. Staying informed about these changes and ensuring compliance is crucial to avoid legal issues. 
In addition to statutory requirements, pay rises are often governed by contractual agreements between employers and employees. 
Employment contracts may include provisions for periodic pay reviews, but these reviews do not necessarily guarantee a pay increase. 
It is essential for businesses to ensure that their contract of employment is worded according to what they wish to do, so that they are not creating a contractual obligation or expectation regarding pay adjustments, when this is not financially possible.  

Balancing fairness and business needs 

It is important to understand that pay rises are typically discretionary decisions made by employers. Even if past practices involved granting certain percentage pay rises, there is typically no automatic entitlement for employees to receive the same increases in the future unless explicitly stated in their contracts. 
Employers have discretion in deciding when and how to award pay rises. However, exercising this discretion requires careful consideration of fairness, non-discrimination, and business needs. 
In addition, aligning pay rises with business needs and financial capabilities is essential for maintaining sustainability. Employers must balance the desire to reward employees with the need to ensure the financial health of the business. 

Ensuring compliance and mitigating legal risks 

While employers have discretion in awarding pay rises, it is crucial to ensure compliance with legal requirements as set out above and mitigate potential legal risks. Breaching contractual obligations regarding pay increases can expose employers to claims for breach of contract, leading to costly legal proceedings and reputational damage. 
To minimize legal risks associated with pay rises, employers should: 
Review employment contracts and any relevant agreements to understand obligations regarding pay adjustments. 
Document the rationale behind pay decisions, including performance evaluations, market comparisons, and budgetary considerations. 
Ensure consistency and fairness in the application of pay policies, avoiding arbitrary or discriminatory practices. 
Provide opportunities for employees to discuss pay-related concerns through open communication. 
By proactively addressing legal compliance and risk mitigation measures, employers can navigate pay rise decisions effectively while upholding legal standards and fostering positive employee relations. 

Considerations to take into account and employee engagement 

Effective pay management is essential for maintaining a motivated and engaged workforce. Below are a few tips that can assist to manage this area: 
Implement performance-based pay structures that link pay increases to individual or team performance outcomes. 
Offer non-monetary rewards and recognition programs to supplement pay increases. 
Consider giving everyone the same percentage increase across the board. 
Provide avenues for employee feedback and input on pay-related matters. 


 In conclusion, understanding pay rises requires navigating legal considerations while balancing fairness, business needs, and employee engagement. While statutory requirements provide a baseline, pay rises are often discretionary decisions guided by contractual agreements and employer judgment.  Employers must ensure compliance with legal requirements regarding pay increases while mitigating potential legal risks. By adopting transparent communication practices, fair criteria for pay decisions, and strategic approaches to pay management, employers can navigate pay rise decisions effectively while fostering positive employee relations and organisational success.  In summary, while pay rises are discretionary decisions, employers can leverage expert guidance and best practices to make informed and compliant decisions that contribute to a motivated and engaged workforce.  

Please do not hesitate to contact if you would like to discuss writing a policy. Taking HR from 'TO DO' to 'DONE'. 
Share this post:

Leave a comment: 

Our site uses cookies. For more information, see our cookie policy. Accept cookies and close
Reject cookies Manage settings