What do you do if your new hire isn't a fit for your business after all? In this post I’ll guide you through managing probation periods effectively, ensuring fairness for your team and protection for your business.
Hiring new talent is exciting, but also worrying. What happens when, despite your best efforts, it just isn't working out during those crucial first few months? It's a common worry for SME owners, and frankly, it can feel like a real headache, impacting team morale and your bottom line. This is where expert HR consultancy services in Milton Keynes can provide invaluable support.
You might be thinking, “Surely that’s what probation is for?” and you’d be right. A well-managed probation period is your opportunity to ensure a new hire truly aligns with your business needs and culture, without unnecessary risk or hassle down the line. It's about getting things right for everyone involved.
What probation actually means for your business
First, let's clear up a common misconception: probation isn't a legal requirement. Instead, it’s a contractual tool, a trial period often included in employment contracts. It allows for a shorter notice period, typically just one week instead of a month or more, and can delay access to certain contractual benefits, like private healthcare.
Crucially, though, your employees still have statutory rights from day one. This includes things like minimum wage, holiday pay, and protection from discrimination. So, while probation offers flexibility, it’s not a free pass to ignore fair process. Getting this balance right protects your business and keeps things fair for your team.
Managing probation properly
The best way to avoid a tricky probation situation is to set a new hire up for success from the very beginning. This isn't just good practice; it's a practical step that makes a lasting difference to your business.
Here’s how to manage probation effectively:
➡️Set clear expectations from the start: provide a proper job description with measurable goals for the first six months. Explain your standards and what good performance looks like. When people know what’s expected, they have a much better chance of meeting it.
➡️Get the basics right: a structured induction is vital. Cover how your business works, introduce them to key people, and provide any necessary training. If problems occur after good onboarding, you’ll know the issue likely isn’t your process, but perhaps a mismatch in skills or attitude.
➡️Review regularly and keep notes: don’t wait for problems to escalate. Hold weekly check-ins at first, moving to monthly as they settle. Document progress, any issues, and agreed actions. Following up with written summaries protects both you and the employee.
➡️Give them a chance to improve: if you spot underperformance, don’t ignore it. Identify the reasons together. Offer support like extra training, clearer instructions, or adjustments to working arrangements. Ask the employee what would help them succeed. This empathetic approach often resolves issues and builds trust.
What to do next if it's still not working
Despite your best efforts, sometimes a new hire just isn't the right fit. When this happens, it’s vital to handle it correctly to protect your business from potential claims and maintain a positive reputation.
✅Consider extending probation: if you need more time to assess performance, you might extend the probation period. This is usually by one month and only if your contract allows it. Make sure you put the reasons and new goals in writing, clearly explaining what needs to improve.
✅If dismissal is necessary, follow a fair process: even during probation, dismissing an employee requires a fair process. This involves:
🟢Inviting them to a meeting in writing, clearly explaining the reasons for concern.
🟢Allowing them to respond and offer their perspective.
🟢Confirming your decision in writing, outlining the notice period.
🟢Offering a right of appeal, which is good practice and further protects your business.
This structured approach might seem like extra work, but it’s an investment in handling challenges with confidence and safeguarding your business.
Future-proofing your probation process
Employment law is always evolving. There are planned changes with the Employment Rights Bill that may introduce day-one or six month protection from unfair dismissal, potentially from 2026–27. This means that strengthening your probation processes now isn't just good practice; it's a proactive step to reduce future risks for your business.
By documenting your probation process clearly, training your managers on how to conduct reviews, and addressing performance concerns early and consistently, you're building stronger teams and cultures that can adapt to future changes.
If you’re finding probation periods a source of stress, or if you want to ensure your processes are robust and compliant, let’s have a conversation.
As an outsourced HR consultant in Milton Keynes, I help small to medium businesses like yours transform their people management. I can review and improve your probation procedures, provide training for your managers, and support you in handling those tricky situations fairly and legally.
Book a confidential call today, and let’s discuss how practical steps can give you legal peace of mind and help you build a team that truly thrives. Please do reach out 📱 0781 3084152 or email 📧 daxa@hrresultsltd.co.uk Taking your HR from 'to do' to 'done'.
Share this post: